Real reviews.
Real impact.

Citarella is a New York-based seafood market and online shop with over a century of experience in sourcing and selling fresh fish, shellfish, caviar, and smoked seafood. The webshop ships fresh and never-frozen seafood directly to customers across the United States.

Your review = Donation to charity + chance on €250

Two minutes of your time. One donation to a good cause, plus a monthly cash raffle.

How it works →
Real photos from real customers

Photo reviews

No glossy product shots, but what customers actually receive at home.

Impact via Citarella (US)

You write a review, we donate to a good cause on your behalf.

No donations have been made for Citarella (US) yet, but every review sets one in motion right away.

Is Citarella (US) your business? Claim this page for free →

At a glance

About Citarella (US)

Founded
Over 100 years ago
Country
United States
Physical locations
10 stores in New York and Connecticut
Shipping method
Overnight shipping
Free shipping
Free overnight shipping on seafood kits (limited time)
Main category
Fresh seafood and gourmet food
Product range
Fish, shellfish, caviar, smoked fish, seafood kits
Delivery area
United States
Citarella positions itself firmly in the premium segment of the seafood market, catering to home cooks, food enthusiasts, and professional chefs who prioritize quality and provenance over price. The business started as a neighborhood fish market on the Upper West Side of Manhattan and has since expanded to ten physical locations across New York and Connecticut, alongside a fully operational online store. The product range spans everyday fish fillets and whole fish to specialty items such as multiple caviar varieties, uni, bottarga, and curated seafood kits, reflecting a philosophy centered on quality sourcing and breadth of selection. Overnight shipping is used to maintain freshness, making the webshop relevant for customers outside of the New York metropolitan area.
June 2026

Active promotions

Ready to use with your order at Citarella (US).

Free overnight shipping on selected seafood kits for a limited period, allowing customers to receive fresh seafood at no extra delivery cost.
To the shop
Seasonal seafood packages available around key holidays such as Passover and Easter, with specific order cutoff times communicated in advance.
To the shop
Recent

Citarella (US) in the news

Recent updates and background about Citarella (US), summarised in our own words.

Transfermarkt

Gabriele Citarella

This item concerns Gabriele Citarella, as listed on Transfermarkt. The available information is limited to the name and the platform on which it appears.

Patch

Citarella Opens New Location in Westhampton Beach

The food retailer Citarella opened a new store in Westhampton Beach. The opening was reported by local news outlet Patch.

Citarella (US)

Shipping Fresh Seafood Overnight

Citarella ships fresh, hand-selected seafood overnight to customers across the United States, ensuring the product arrives at peak freshness. Orders can be placed directly through the online shop.

Summaries by Image Review based on publicly available sources and our own editing. External links may contain affiliate links.

Frequently asked questions

What others ask about Citarella (US)

Answers to the most common questions, based on search behaviour and our own research.

Is Citarella a trustworthy online seafood shop?

Citarella has been operating as a seafood market for over 100 years, originally as a neighborhood fish market in New York City. The business now runs ten physical store locations and an online shop, which provides a degree of accountability and track record that many online-only retailers do not have.

How does Citarella ship fresh fish without it going bad?

Citarella uses overnight shipping to ensure that fresh and never-frozen seafood arrives at peak freshness. Products are hand-selected before dispatch.

Does Citarella offer free shipping?

Free overnight shipping is available on seafood kits, though this offer is described as limited in time. Standard shipping terms for other products are not specified in the available information.

Can I order seafood online from Citarella if I do not live in New York?

Yes, Citarella operates an online shop that ships seafood across the United States using overnight delivery. The webshop is designed for customers who do not have access to one of the ten physical store locations.

Your turn

Do you have experience with Citarella (US)?

Help other consumers by sharing your experience, with a photo of what you actually received. It takes two minutes and you automatically join the monthly draw.

250
cash per month
One winner from all review submitters, drawn on the 1st of the month.

Your review = real impact + chance to win €250

Guarantee: every review triggers one of these 5 real donations:

  1. 1 Upload a photo Of your order or the product
  2. 2 Give stars 1 to 5 per aspect
  3. 3 Trigger a donation Plus a chance at € 250 cash per month
Write a review

Share your photo review about Citarella (US)

A photo says more than a thousand words. Help other consumers with an honest experience and join the monthly draw for € 250 cash.

  • Reviewing anonymously is fine, we only need your email
  • No mandatory account, no registration
  • Reviews appear after a check within 24 hours
  • Monthly chance to win € 250 cash

Your rating

Take a photo or upload one *
JPG or PNG, max 10 MB
Or drag a file here
✓ Photo uploaded Click to choose a different photo
Product
Service
Price
Delivery
We use your email to send your ticket number.

By clicking you agree to the Terms and Conditions and Campaign Terms. Read our Privacy Policy for how we secure your data.

Scroll to Top